Introduction
A pain scale is a structured form that turns what you see and feel in a patient into a number. Technicians score patients in recovery, on hospital rounds, after a rescue dose and at recheck visits. The number matters because it tells the team when to treat and whether the treatment worked.
There is no "gold standard" test for pain in animals, and many published scales have never been validated.1 This guide covers the Glasgow, Colorado State University (CSU) and UNESP-Botucatu scales, the Feline Grimace Scale and the owner questionnaires used for chronic pain: what each scores, its range, its intervention level and how to act on the result.
Key facts
- Glasgow CMPS-SF (dog, acute): 6 categories, maximum 24. Analgesia is indicated at 6/24 or more, or 5/20 or more when mobility cannot be assessed.2
- Glasgow CMPS-Feline (cat, acute): maximum 20, intervention at 5/20 or more.2
- Feline Grimace Scale: 5 action units (ear position, orbital tightening, muzzle tension, whiskers, head position), each scored 0, 1 or 2. Rescue analgesia is indicated when the total is above 0.39 out of 1.0.3
- UNESP-Botucatu multidimensional scale (cat): maximum 30, intervention above 7/30. Its short form (UFEPS-SF) has 4 items, maximum 12, rescue at 4/12 or more.25
- CSU acute pain scales score 0 (normal) to 4 (severe). They began as teaching tools and have no validated intervention score.26
- Chronic pain is scored by owners: CBPI and LOAD for dogs with osteoarthritis, FMPI for cats with degenerative joint disease.1611
- A low score does not rule out pain. If pain is likely, analgesia should be given, and the response to an analgesic is the most accurate test.1
How the VTNE tests this
- Recognize need for analgesia (Domain 9 Task B; K44 "Pain assessment and analgesic administration techniques").14 Expect "this patient scores X; what do you do next?"
- Choose the right tool: match species (dog or cat) and pain type (acute or chronic) to a scale, or pick the owner questionnaire for osteoarthritis.
- Know the numbers: maximum scores and intervention levels for the CMPS-SF, CMPS-Feline, UNESP-Botucatu and Feline Grimace Scale.
- Calculate: a Feline Grimace Scale total when one action unit cannot be scored, or a CMPS-SF total without the mobility item.
- Support the plan and educate the client (Domain 9 Task C; Domain 10 Task A, which lists pain assessment and management among client education topics).14
Core concepts
Why scoring beats guessing
Pain is an individual experience with sensory and emotional parts.2 Normal species behavior can mask it, and the signs are often not what people expect. A dog may wag its tail and greet you while in pain. A cat sitting quietly at the back of the cage after surgery may be in pain even though it is not pacing or crying.1 A validated scale gives every observer the same checklist.
Scales based on the presence or absence of species-specific behaviors are likely to be more accurate than generic scales that rely on the observer's interpretation.1 Even so, observers disagree. One study found 29% to 36% variation between veterinarians using simple descriptive, numerical and visual analog scales, and similar variation has been reported for the CMPS-SF.6 Using one scale, the same way, every time reduces that noise.
Why vital signs are not enough
Heart rate, respiratory rate, blood pressure and pupil size can rise with acute pain, particularly under anesthesia. They are not specific: they cannot separate pain from fear, anxiety or metabolic conditions such as anemia, and animals with chronic pain may have normal values.1 Normal vital signs never prove that a patient is comfortable.
Validated, intervention level and terms you need
- Validated: the scale has been tested to show it measures pain (validity), gives similar results between observers (reliability) and changes after treatment (responsiveness). A 2026 systematic review rated the UNESP-Botucatu scale, its short form and the Feline Grimace Scale as having the highest quality of evidence, and found that dog scales generally had weaker evidence than cat scales.2
- Intervention level (also called the cut-off or rescue threshold): the score at which analgesia is recommended. Some scales use "this score or more" (CMPS-SF, 6/24 or more) and others use "above this score" (FGS, above 0.39). The CSU scales do not have one.2
- Clinical metrology instrument (CMI): a questionnaire completed by the owner or caregiver that scores chronic pain or mobility at home.11
Acute pain scales used in hospital
Glasgow CMPS-SF (dog). The short form scores six categories: vocalization, attention to the wound, mobility, response to touch, demeanor and posture/activity. In each category you pick the description that best matches the dog, and the ranked scores are added. The maximum is 24, or 20 if mobility cannot be assessed.6 Analgesia is indicated at 6/24 or more, or 5/20 or more without mobility.2
Glasgow CMPS-Feline (cat). The definitive feline version scores observation, approach and interaction, palpation and a general impression, with a maximum of 20 and an intervention level of 5/20 or more.2 It includes two facial features, the ears and the muzzle.3
CSU acute pain scales (dog and cat). These were first created as educational tools. They are scored on a 0 to 4 scale2 using behavioral signs, response to palpation and body tension.6 The canine scale is listed as not validated, and the feline scale has no defined analgesic intervention score.26
UNESP-Botucatu scales (cat). The multidimensional composite scale was developed using cats after ovariohysterectomy. It scores psychomotor change, protection of the wound, physiologic variables and vocal expression, maximum 30, with intervention above 7/30.2 The short form (UFEPS-SF) scores posture, activity, attitude and reaction to touch and palpation of the painful site, each 0 to 3, for a maximum of 12. Rescue analgesia is given at 4/12 or more.5
Feline Grimace Scale (FGS). The FGS scores five facial action units. Ear position: the ear tips are pulled apart and rotated outward. Orbital tightening: the eyes narrow or squint. Muzzle tension: the muzzle flattens from round to elliptical. Whiskers: they move forward and away from the face. Head position: the head is below the shoulder line or tilted down. Each unit is scored 0 (absent), 1 (moderate or uncertain) or 2 (obvious). The total is the sum divided by the maximum possible, so it runs from 0 to 1.0, and a unit you cannot see is left out of both numbers.3 Rescue analgesia is indicated above 0.39.3 The developers describe it as usable by both veterinary professionals and cat owners.15
| Scale | Species | Acute or chronic | Scoring range | Intervention level | Validation (who) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Glasgow CMPS-SF | Dog | Acute (postoperative) | 0 to 24 (0 to 20 without mobility) | 6/24 or more; 5/20 or more | Reid and colleagues, 2007 (Glasgow); listed as partially validated |
| Glasgow CMPS-Feline | Cat | Acute | 0 to 20 | 5/20 or more | Reid and colleagues, 2017 (Glasgow) |
| CSU Canine and Feline Acute Pain Scales | Dog, cat | Acute | 0 to 4 | None defined | Colorado State University; canine scale not validated, feline scale preliminary data only |
| UNESP-Botucatu multidimensional scale | Cat | Acute (postoperative) | 0 to 30 | Above 7/30 | Sao Paulo State University (Unesp) group; high-quality evidence |
| UNESP-Botucatu short form (UFEPS-SF) | Cat | Acute | 0 to 12 | 4/12 or more | Unesp group; high-quality evidence |
| Feline Grimace Scale | Cat | Acute | 0 to 1.0 | Above 0.39 | Universite de Montreal group (Evangelista and colleagues, 2019); high-quality evidence |
| Canine Brief Pain Inventory (CBPI) | Dog | Chronic (osteoarthritis, bone cancer) | Each item 0 to 10 | Not used as a rescue cut-off | Owner questionnaire, validated for osteoarthritis and bone cancer |
| Liverpool Osteoarthritis in Dogs (LOAD) | Dog | Chronic (osteoarthritis) | 13 items | Change of 4 points is the suggested meaningful difference | Owner questionnaire, University of Liverpool group |
| Feline Musculoskeletal Pain Index (FMPI) | Cat | Chronic (degenerative joint disease) | Short form: 9 items | Not used as a rescue cut-off | Owner questionnaire; forms available from North Carolina State University |
Sources: Lee and Steagall 20262; Sander 20256; Evangelista 20193; Belli 20215; Merck1; CBPI, LOAD and FMPI papers.891011
Chronic pain tools completed by owners
Chronic pain signs such as less activity, less grooming and a smaller appetite are subtle and not specific, so owner observations are essential.1 The tools below are questionnaires the owner fills in. Your job is to give the same tool each visit, check that it is complete and put the score in the record.
- Canine Brief Pain Inventory (CBPI): four pain severity items and six pain interference items, each on a 0 to 10 scale, plus one quality of life item. The severity and interference scores are the means of each set.8 It is validated for canine osteoarthritis and bone cancer.1
- Liverpool Osteoarthritis in Dogs (LOAD): an owner-completed instrument with 13 mobility and activity items.69 Its authors currently recommend a change of 4 points as the minimal clinically important difference.10
- Feline Musculoskeletal Pain Index (FMPI): the most widely studied cat questionnaire for degenerative joint disease. The short form has nine mobility and daily activity items scored from "normal" to "not at all".11
- Feline Musculoskeletal Pain Screening Checklist (MiPSC): six yes or no items. Any "no" (activity not normal) should prompt further evaluation.11
Procedure or technique
Scoring an acute pain patient on rounds
- Check the order sheet for analgesics given, their times and any rescue order.
- Use the hospital's chosen scale for that species, and the same scale for every score in this stay.
- Observe from outside the kennel first. Look at posture, activity, facial expression and attention to the wound before you open the door. In the FGS clinical study, cats were watched undisturbed for three minutes before anyone interacted with them, and sedation was scored before pain.4 When the same study scored FGS images, it did not use frames where the cat was sleeping, grooming or vocalizing,4 so score the face when the cat is awake, settled and facing you.
- Approach and interact. Call the patient, open the door and note the response. Demeanor is a scored item on composite scales such as the CMPS-SF.6
- Touch near the wound or painful area gently when the scale asks for it, and walk the dog if mobility is scored and the patient is allowed to walk. If mobility cannot be assessed, score the CMPS-SF out of 20.6
- Add up the score, compare it with the intervention level and follow Figure 1.
- Record it. Write the scale name, score out of the maximum, time, your initials and what you did about it.
- Re-score after any analgesic, once the drug has had time to act. In one feline study, cats were re-scored 60 minutes after methadone and 90 minutes after dipyrone, timed to each drug's pharmacokinetics.5
How often to score
Your hospital protocol sets the interval. Research protocols show what frequent scoring looks like: in one FGS study cats were scored at 0.5, 1, 2, 3, 4, 6, 8, 12 and 24 hours after extubation,4 and in a UNESP-Botucatu study cats were scored every hour for the first 6 hours after extubation.5 Score more often early after surgery and after every rescue dose. Chronic pain needs frequent reassessment too, because treatment is adjusted over time.7
| Step | What you do | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Before you touch | Watch posture, face, activity and wound attention from outside the kennel | Handling changes behavior; the FGS is scored on an undisturbed cat |
| Interaction | Call, approach, open the door, note demeanor | Demeanor and response to people are scored items |
| Touch and movement | Gentle pressure near the wound; walk the dog if allowed | Response to touch and mobility are CMPS-SF categories |
| Score | Total out of the right maximum (24 or 20 for the CMPS-SF) | The intervention level depends on the maximum used |
| Act | At or above the intervention level, notify the veterinarian and give rescue analgesia as ordered | Treat pain promptly |
| Re-score | After the drug has had time to act | Shows whether the treatment worked |
| Record | Scale, score, maximum, time, initials, action | Lets the next shift compare scores |
Sources: Evangelista and colleagues 20204; Sander and colleagues 20256; Lee and Steagall 20262; Belli and colleagues 2021.5
Flowchart: score, intervene, re-score
The second question in the tree matters. The Merck Veterinary Manual states that even when animals score low on pain scales, analgesia should be given if pain is considered likely, and that giving an analgesic and watching the response is the most accurate way to find out whether a patient is in pain.1 In the UNESP-Botucatu validation study, observers gave analgesia to some cats that scored below 4/12 when they felt the cat could be in pain.5
Species differences
Dogs
The Glasgow CMPS-SF is the pain scale used most often in small animal medicine.6 Remember that dog scales overall have weaker validation evidence than cat scales.2 Social dogs may greet you and wag while painful,1 so score every item rather than judging by the greeting. For chronic pain, use the CBPI, LOAD or the Helsinki Chronic Pain Index (HCPI), all completed by the owner.16
Cats
Cats have the best-validated acute tools: the UNESP-Botucatu scales and the FGS.2 A painful cat may simply sit still and quiet.1 The FGS is fast to use,15 is scored by watching the cat without interacting with it, and was not affected by acepromazine and buprenorphine sedation in one study.4 For chronic pain, use the FMPI or the MiPSC screening checklist.11
Horses, food animals and exotics
Grimace scales have also been developed for mice, rats, rabbits, horses, sheep, lambs, piglets and ferrets.1 Physiologic changes are useful in some settings, such as horses with acute colic.1 Flock animals such as sheep may hide pain by staying bunched up in the flock when an observer approaches.1
Calculation
Worked example: Feline Grimace Scale with one action unit you cannot see.
A cat is 2 hours out of surgery. Ears: 1. Orbital tightening: 2. Muzzle tension: 1. Head position: 1. The whiskers are hidden by a bandage, so that unit is "not possible to score".
- Sum of the units you scored: 1 + 2 + 1 + 1 = 5 points.
- Maximum possible for the units you scored: 4 units x 2 points/unit = 8 points.
- FGS total = 5 points / 8 points = 0.625 (points cancel, leaving a number between 0 and 1).
- Compare: 0.625 is above 0.39, so rescue analgesia is indicated. Report to the veterinarian and give the ordered drug.3
The developers' own example is 4/10 = 0.4, which is also above 0.39.3 With all five units scored, a raw total of 4 or more out of 10 is above the cut-off.
CMPS-SF without mobility: a dog on strict cage rest scores 5 on the five remaining items. The maximum is 20, and 5/20 meets the intervention level.2 Writing "5" alone looks like a low score out of 24.
Safety, legal and client education
- Handle painful patients with care. Patients with cancer pain may have pronounced wind-up (heightened) pain and should not be handled without a thorough evaluation.7 Observe first and touch last.
- Stay in your scope. Technicians score, report and give drugs as ordered. Technicians cannot diagnose, but they frequently identify signs of chronic pain in conversations with owners and during routine checks, and they are well placed to run pain monitoring clinics.11 Laws on technician duties vary between countries.11
- Document every score with the scale name, score and maximum, time, observer and action taken. Because observers vary, a clear record of who scored and with which scale lets the next shift interpret a change.6
- Use the official forms. Each scale belongs to its developers. Use the current form or app from the developer, not a copy passed around the hospital (see the figure links below for the FGS and the UNESP-Botucatu scales).
- Coach owners. For chronic pain, ask the owner to complete the same questionnaire each visit and explain that a rising score is a reason to call. Owner observations are essential for spotting subtle chronic pain.1 For cats after discharge, the FGS developers state that it can be used by cat owners as well as veterinary professionals.15
- Follow current guidance. The WSAVA Global Guidelines for the Recognition, Assessment and Treatment of Pain were updated in 2022 (published in the Journal of Small Animal Practice in 2023) and include protocols for situations such as castration and ovariohysterectomy, degenerative joint disease, and emergency and critical care.1213
Common mistakes and exam traps
- "Quiet means comfortable." A quiet cat at the back of the cage may be in pain.1
- Using heart rate as the pain score. Vital signs are not specific for pain and can be normal in chronic pain.1
- Forgetting the 20-point CMPS-SF. If mobility is not assessed, the maximum is 20 and the intervention level is 5/20.2
- Giving the CSU scale a cut-off. The CSU scales run 0 to 4 and have no validated intervention score.26
- Dividing the FGS by 10 when a unit was not scored. Divide by the maximum for the units you actually scored.3
- Using an acute hospital scale for osteoarthritis at home. Chronic pain is tracked with owner questionnaires such as the CBPI, LOAD or FMPI.111
Quick review
- There is no gold standard for pain in animals; use a validated, species-specific scale.
- Glasgow CMPS-SF: 6 categories, act at 6/24 or more, or 5/20 or more without mobility.
- Glasgow CMPS-Feline: maximum 20, act at 5/20 or more.
- UNESP-Botucatu (cat): act above 7/30; short form act at 4/12 or more.
- Feline Grimace Scale: 5 action units scored 0 to 2, total 0 to 1.0, act above 0.39.
- FGS total = points scored divided by maximum possible for the units scored.
- CSU scales: 0 to 4, teaching tools, no validated intervention score.
- Cat scales currently have stronger validation evidence than dog scales.
- Vital signs are not specific for pain and may be normal in chronic pain.
- Chronic pain: CBPI, LOAD and HCPI for dogs; FMPI and MiPSC for cats; completed by owners.
- Observe first, then interact, then touch; re-score after every analgesic dose.
- A low score does not rule out pain; report it if pain is still likely.